Villa Sorrento
Villa Sorrento
Villa Sorrento

Villa Sorrento

Italian, Steak

We invite you to come taste the experience at Villa Sorrento. Open seven days a week, serving lunch and dinner Monday through Thursday from 11:30 am until 10:00 pm, Friday from 11:30 am until 11:00 pm, and for dinner only on Saturday from 4:00 until 11:00 pm and Sunday from 2:00 until 9:00 pm. Our menu includes a wide variety of dishes such as fresh seafood, pasta, and steak to name a few. Begin your dining experience with a cocktail at our bar. We offer an extensive wine list featuring popular varieties. A Vintners Reserve selection is also available. Enjoy your meal in one of our two dining areas where earth tone decor along with the glow of our fireplace will set the tone for a relaxing evening. Specials are prepared daily and take out is available.

Exclusive deals

These exclusive deals are only available to Restaurant.com members. Check back often as new offers are added daily.

$10 Off Deal for $5.00
Minimum purchase of $20.00 required at the restaurant. Dine In Only. Not valid for Friday and Saturday.

Dining Discount Pass

Get discounts at over 170,000 restaurants and retailers nationwide.

Explore more great deals nearby!


Location and hours

Location

Location

823 Middle Country Rd , Saint James, NY

(631) 265-9865

Hours

Hours

Monday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Thursday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Friday 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Saturday 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Sunday 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

More details

Delivery
Dine In
Reservations
Takeout
Pickup
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Accessible

Reviews

Overall rating

star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
4.5

(73 reviews)

star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on July 5, 2020 Verified Purchase

The bread was extra tasty: crisp crust with sesame seeds and a hot, fluffy, interior

RH
Ron H.
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on July 28, 2019 Verified Purchase

Food was quite good,but the portions were on the "light" side

RH
Ron H.
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on January 30, 2016 Verified Purchase

The swordfish had a fishy taste. Everything else was great.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on July 6, 2014 Verified Purchase

Dezzie is the best and reason we come back....I do wish the lights were a little brighter there...makes reading their extensive menu hard

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on May 31, 2014 Verified Purchase

very good

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on May 3, 2014 Verified Purchase

I ordered the Filet Oscar, the oysters were delicious and cooked to perfection. Was happy to see more than the 2 oysters with this entree. My filet was undercooked,so I sent it back, cooked to perfection and so tender when it came back. This is my favorite restaurant to dine. My husband was pleased with his ribeye also.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on February 8, 2014 Verified Purchase

The dining room was cold, had to leave coats on

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on February 7, 2014 Verified Purchase

We love coming here. Always treated like family with a heart-felt welcome from Gia and the rest of the staff. From the dinners to the sandwiches, the appetizers to the pizza, we are never disappointed. Come in and give them a try, you won't be disappointed! Be back soon...........

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on January 15, 2014 Verified Purchase

Great service!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star gray star gray
Reviewed on January 13, 2014 Verified Purchase

We've been to this restaurant on numerous occasions and always been very satisfied, but I fear tonight's experience may be our last trip. While the food was decent, the supposedly fresh bread was stale, the salad only contained lettuce and a heavy vinegar dressing, and the wait staff left much to be desired; in fact, our waitress was so apathetic I wasn't even sure she wanted to be there or do her job! Drink orders had to be forced on her. She brought water and we had to ask if we could have something else to drink. Food was brought out promptly but the dessert experience was the worst. We asked what they had for dessert for which the waitress replied, "it's in the dessert carousel." So apparently my husband and I had to get up from our table and stand around as the carousel of desserts spun by. Not the classiest experience. To make matters even worse, we decided to split two different desserts, one chocolate and one apple strudel. Both tasted a little on the stale side but the chocolate one was not edible. It was so dry we couldn't choke it down. We told the waitress this and her reply was,"I ate it earlier and it was good to me." We also went to the restaurant on a Mon evening. She informed us that the desserts were made Sat. The dessert carousel is refrigerated but the desserts are not covered up. If I stuck a piece of chocolate cake in my fridge uncovered for 2 days it would be dried out too! We were offered no compensation for this except an offer to take a cheese Danish home, which we declined. We still had to pay the $5 for the uneaten dessert. Needless to say, until some better waitstaff and consistent food are present we won't be back. After paying $27 for beef stroganoff (which was delicious) I expect to have a better overall experience.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on December 2, 2013 Verified Purchase

Love the food at Lefty's! Had an appetite for crab cakes and knew Lefty's recipe is the best!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on August 19, 2013 Verified Purchase

Excellent setting in Saratoga

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on August 17, 2013 Verified Purchase

It took a long time to get the food

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on July 29, 2013 Verified Purchase

Personalized attention, very creative menu.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on July 6, 2013 Verified Purchase

friendly staff, well cooked, tasty meals.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on July 6, 2013 Verified Purchase

Always good food and great service

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on July 3, 2013 Verified Purchase

Great food but poor and extremely service

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on July 2, 2013 Verified Purchase

one waitress, food was a little slow coming.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star gray star gray star gray
Reviewed on January 21, 2013 Verified Purchase

Loved the Osso Bucco, but the sauce for the Salmon was way too heavy. Loved the fireplace. Service was by two waiters who were very nice, but left gaps

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on January 21, 2013 Verified Purchase

Had a nice romantic dinner with my husband. It was a very nice time. Would reccomend it to couples.

DU
Default U.
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on January 8, 2013 Verified Purchase

Service is great & they are very attentive

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on January 8, 2013 Verified Purchase

Friendly staff with great food.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on October 20, 2012 Verified Purchase

The food there is incredible!!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on October 14, 2012 Verified Purchase

Terrific Service, great food and nice ambiance. A very enjoyable experience.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on September 11, 2012 Verified Purchase

food and service is excellent, it is prepared to your liking

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on July 15, 2012 Verified Purchase

The main reason I tried restaurnt.com was because you (Villa Sorrento) were a participant and I had eaten there before.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on June 30, 2012 Verified Purchase

very warm and enviting with outstanding service. Cant wait to try it again!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star gray star gray
Reviewed on June 30, 2012 Verified Purchase

They are overpriced, they added on an exorbitant tip to our bill, they didn't even refill our water glasses. We have eaten far better food and larger portions for less money elsewhere

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on June 23, 2012 Verified Purchase

The food and service is always fabulous at Villa Sorrento and I would recommend highly.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on May 30, 2012 Verified Purchase

Great food! We'll be back!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on April 25, 2012 Verified Purchase

great restaurant! Thank you restaurants.com for introducing it to me!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on April 25, 2012 Verified Purchase

I have always found Villa Sorrento to be a reliable to eat Italian, well-prepared, reasonably priced food. It is a place I will return to.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star gray star gray star gray star gray
Reviewed on April 11, 2012 Verified Purchase

Salt should be used to accent a food's flavor, not overpower it. Every item had far too much salt, among other problems. Servers should ask if uneaten meals are to be wrapped (if only for the dog) or if there was a problem with the meal.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star gray star gray
Reviewed on April 5, 2012 Verified Purchase

We picked the wrong evening to visit Villa Sorrento. There was a private party of well over 50 people that had taken over the restaurant. The noise level was pretty high. The staff tried to be accomodating - moving us to a very cramped high-top table at the bar until the noise level quieted down. We were there for about 10-15 minutes until they shuffled us back to the original table. While the noise was better, it never felt like the intimate dinner we were looking to have. The waiter or staff never offered to do anything for our inconvenience - just offered to shuffle us back and forth. A gesture of something simple like complementary coffee or dessert would have gone a long way to acknowledge the fiasco. The food was decent. We ordered the tuna steak and one of the house specials (bowtie pasta with seafood). The tuna was excellent while the seafood special left a little to be desired. We dine regularly in the area and were overall unimpressed. The bread basket that was served was a bit dry and burnt.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on April 4, 2012 Verified Purchase

Wonderful dining experience.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star gray star gray
Reviewed on March 21, 2012 Verified Purchase

Dined on a slow Sunday evening. Food quality was good. Service very poor. Non-attentive. I sat for over 30 minutes w/out drink (water glass & wine glass empty). Dined at Lombardi's two nights prior -- hands down far superior.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on March 14, 2012 Verified Purchase

Service was excellent, food was delish!!!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on March 14, 2012 Verified Purchase

Great Meal! Great Service! Fabulous Italian Food!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on March 8, 2012 Verified Purchase

Excellent food and service

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on March 6, 2012 Verified Purchase

The food is fresh, the portions are satisfying. The selections are interesting. The staff helpful and friendly.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on March 6, 2012 Verified Purchase

Womnderful service

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on March 6, 2012 Verified Purchase

very nice

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on March 6, 2012 Verified Purchase

Wine list very pricey, they charge $32 for a $10 bottle of wine!Food is GOOD!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on March 6, 2012 Verified Purchase

Excellent meal and service!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on February 12, 2012 Verified Purchase

Their $30 bottles of wine on their winelist you can buy down the street for less than $10 a bottle.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star gray star gray star gray
Reviewed on February 12, 2012 Verified Purchase

Good food. Nice atmosphere

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star gray star gray
Reviewed on February 11, 2012 Verified Purchase

the service was outstanding but the food wasn't to good

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on February 11, 2012 Verified Purchase

I was disappointed with the taste of the salmon special. The fish did not taste fresh. Everything else was great.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on January 19, 2012 Verified Purchase

You are treated very well and the food is excellent.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on January 4, 2012 Verified Purchase

This restaurant is now among my TOP favorites. The quality of food and services is supreme.The ambiance is incomparable.They have achieved the "non-commercial" atmosphere so lacking in most restaurants.A rare jewel. Irecommend it highly

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on January 4, 2012 Verified Purchase

Where do I start John makes sure everything is taken care of at the bar and Walter Handles the food and George makes sure you food is cooked to profection and Armondo makes sure its delivered promply

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on December 28, 2011 Verified Purchase

Restaurant.com procedures and limits on use of pre-paid coupons are burdensome. Whenb I purchasd $50 gift cards I assumed I could use $50. Your restrictions after the fact limit me to only $25 per visit. This is last time I would ever use restaurant.com

JG
Joseph G.
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on December 28, 2011 Verified Purchase

I thought the food, service and ambiance were fantastic.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on December 22, 2011 Verified Purchase

Great Place! Walter's (manager) only interest was making sure that our dining experience was perfect! and it was!We are now "regulars" at this nice restaurant!Steven Krinsky

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on December 22, 2011 Verified Purchase

The restaurant was extremely noisy making it difficult to hold a conversation. Otherwise it was a very good experience.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on December 20, 2011 Verified Purchase

Great food and service!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on December 14, 2011 Verified Purchase

I think the food and service are excellent and enjoy eathin there

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star gray star gray star gray
Reviewed on November 30, 2011 Verified Purchase

Small local restaurant in our town, convenient to home, artichoke appetizer was good, grouper fish entree was dry &overcooked, short rib entree was good, would go back for pasta next time not fish...

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on November 24, 2011 Verified Purchase

We were at the restaurant to celebrate our anniversary, and everything was perfect!!!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on November 21, 2011 Verified Purchase

If you want to have the best dinning experience you have ever had you should try Villa Sorrento's. George will make you a meal you will never forget Walter will make sure you have a great dinning Experience and of course John will take care of all your beverage needs (at the bar) ans Sal will be there to also make sure your Dinner was spectacular. Thanks Villa Serrento's

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on November 15, 2011 Verified Purchase

I enjoyed this restaurant very much, The food was fabulous, the server couldnt have been nicer. I will definitely go back to this restaurant.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on November 15, 2011 Verified Purchase

we enjoyed everything food, sevice and restaurant itself very pretty

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on November 15, 2011 Verified Purchase

excellent restaurant! So happy they participate in restaurants.com. As long as they participate...We will be there!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on October 13, 2011 Verified Purchase

Always good food and good service. Would go more if we lived closer.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star gray
Reviewed on October 5, 2011 Verified Purchase

We had a very pleasurable evening out with personable service and great food - wonderful!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on October 5, 2011 Verified Purchase

I am so happy this restaurant participates in restaurants.com. It is my new favorite place! I never would have ate there unless they participated!

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on September 16, 2011 Verified Purchase

A wonderfule experience.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on September 3, 2011 Verified Purchase

always delicious

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on August 19, 2011 Verified Purchase

REALLY like this place. One of the best Italian restaurants in Suffolk County. Friendly owner/manager/staff. SOLID meal. SOLID value. Would like a better wine list, but their current one is good. Looking forward to our next meal there. Won't be long...

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on August 17, 2011 Verified Purchase

Food, service and atmosphere were all excellent.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star gray star gray star gray
Reviewed on August 10, 2011 Verified Purchase

We had been there once before on a Sat night.The food was very good (after a 2 hr wait for table).This time it was Sun eve and was disappointed.I ordered the special which was on AngelHair pasta,but received spaghetti.My husband's dish was just OK. There were only 3 other tables of diners, but waitress was hard to flag down- never made eye contact.Hope it was just an "off" night.Will try one more time.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on August 10, 2011 Verified Purchase

An overall enjoyable experience. We will be coming back.

GD
Guest Diner
star filled star filled star filled star filled star filled
Reviewed on July 20, 2011 Verified Purchase

Wonderful food - nice people

GD
Guest Diner

Login to write a review